Author: Betty Turpin

Culture: Beliefs and Values #2: Henry Hikes to Fitchburg

Lesson Overview:

This is a beautiful lesson about choices based on values.  Essentially, it asks the children to think about whether they would rather do work to earn money or have a long day exploring the natural world.  D.B. Johnson’s adaptation of the work of Henry David Thoreau is brilliant!  Students who have had a lot of outdoor experiences will have much to share in this lesson.  The lesson is also a great one for giving children the chance to make a decision and defend or explain their choice with evidence from the text.

Lesson Plan:

Suggested Grades:

1-5

Objective:

Identify personal values and beliefs of characters in a story using both textual and visual clues.

Suggested Time:

35-45 minutes

Success Criteria:

Each student will complete a T-Chart that will help them draw conclusions about the characters.  The T-Chart will also give them material to structure their thinking and reflect on a few of their own values.

Lesson Outline:

1. Introduction:

Every day when I come to school I have to decide whether to come by a) car b) bicycle or c)  train.  I have choices.  Sometimes my choice depends on the weather or how I am feeling.  But, most of the time the choice I make depends on my values.

In today’s story, two characters have to make a choice and they choose very different ways of accomplishing the same thing.  Listen carefully.  Keep track of what the characters do.  See if you can figure out what each character values based on his actions.

2. Main:

Show the text.  Pass out the assignment.  Go over the instructions together.

Teach the story, allowing kids to fill in the T-Chart and take simple notes.  Scribe for them on a flipchart so that they do not get hung up on spellings

Down one side, list the chores done by Henry’s friend.  Down the other side, list the adventures Henry has on his hike.

3. Conclusion:

Ask the students if they think each of the friends was satisfied with his choices.  Then complete the first two questions together:  What did Henry’s friend value?  What did Henry value?  Talk about it and give the kids a moment to answer these questions.

Finally, ask the students to think about what they would choose if faced with the same decision.  Would they work to earn money for a ticket or would they walk?  Have them write their answers (or discuss their answer with an elbow partner if you are running short on time).  This is a great reflection/thinking question.  After the story, the children should have enough ideas and evidence to form a convincing opinion.

additional Resources:
  1. Henry Hikes to Fitchburg by D.B. Johnson.
  2. Flipchart
  3. Markers
  4. Copies of the student handout
  5. Pencils
  6. Clipboards
Notes:

Johnson’s book is a children’s adaptation of some of the work of Henry David Thoreau.  Johnson’s other books in the Henry series evoke the ideas in Walden beautifully and effectively.   I am a huge fan of the Henry series and find that the texts adapt for many purposes.  For example, I use Henry Hikes to Fitchburg for lessons on:

  • Beliefs and values
  • Transportation
  • Business/Economics

Also note that a lot of today’s children do not have experience completing these simple chores.  I am often shocked at how few of them have swept out a room.  Be careful with parts like “cleaning the henhouse.”  Most kids think that that means collecting eggs!

Key Terms:

Values, Beliefs, Transportation, Trains, Chores, Walden, Henry David Thoreau, Nature, Industry, Money, Business and Economics

recommended texts:
  1. Henry Hikes to Fitchburg by D.B. Johnson.
student handout:

Student Handout. Henry Hikes to Fitchburg

Culture: Beliefs and Values #1: How Books Are Valued by Cultures Around the World

Lesson Overview:

Based on the work of Margriet Ruurs, this is a tremendously powerful lesson for helping children understand the importance of community or school libraries.  Quite often children in developed countries take for granted the many privileges they enjoy.  In this lesson, they get a glimpse of the countless ways communities all over the world receive library books and the dedicated volunteers and librarians who deliver them.

Lesson Plan:

Suggested Grades:

3-5

Objective:

To understand that books are valued in cultures around the world.

AASL 2.3.2:  Consider diverse and global perspectives in drawing conclusions.

AASL 4.4.4:  Interpret new information based on cultural and social context.

Suggested Time:

35-45 minutes

Success Criteria:

Students will identify four different countries and the ways library books are brought to school children in those countries/cultures.

Lesson Outline:

1. Introduction:

Ask which of the children have books at home.  Ask which of the children have libraries in their home country(ies).  Ask why books are so prevalent in homes around the world.  Emphasize that most cultures value education and believe that having access to books is a great way to help children learn and enable them to have fun.

2. Main:

Summarize or paraphrase relevant sections of the text.  The book is too long to read it in its entirety, so I usually choose a few different sections.  The kids respond particularly well to:

  • Australia – Trucks (a familiar transport vehicle).
  • Finland – Boats (also familiar to most students).
  • Thailand – Elephant! Describe the rural northern Thailand terrain and let them guess . . . sometimes they can!
  • Kenya – Camel. They love looking at this picture.  Ask if they think you, as a librarian, could organize the mules, camels, or elephants!

I like to start with highlights from the foreword, because in it the author explains that she wondered how kids around the world got their books.  Point out that she had a question, did her own personal inquiry, kept notes, and eventually turned that work into a book.  This is a fabulous example of a grown-up doing inquiry work.  Our students learn through inquiry, and this shows how powerful and effective personal inquiry can be!

Be sure to use a globe so that the children know where in the world the examples come from.

3. Conclusion:

Reiterate that books are brought to kids around the world because people believe that having access to books is important for children.

additional Resources:
  1. My Librarian is a Camel: How Books Are Brought to Children Around the World by Margriet Ruurs.
  2. Student Handout (see attached.)
  3. Map or globe
Notes:
Key Terms:

Libraries, Traveling Libraries, Librarians, Camels

Recommended Texts:
  1. My Librarian is a Camel: How Books Are Brought to Children Around the World by Margriet Ruurs.
student handout:

Student Handout, My Librarian is a Camel

Culture: Beliefs and Values #3: Ruby’s Wish: The Value of Education for Girls and Boys

Lesson Overview:

Most students have an innate sense of what is fair and unfair.  They can also be quite vocal in expressing their displeasure when they feel that they have been ill-treated.  In this lesson, preference is given to girls.  We purposefully provoke the students then introduce them to a story in which children’s lives were determined, to a large degree, by gender.  The big idea is the value of education, but there will be a lot of discussion about fairness and gender.

Lesson Plan:

Suggested Grades:

3-5

Objective:

To understand how a culture values education for both girls and boys.

AASL 2.3.2 “Consider diverse and global perspectives in drawing conclusions.”

AASL 4.4.4 “Interpret new information based on cultural and social context.”

Suggested Time:

35-45 minutes

Success Criteria:

Students will be able to express an opinion about how Ruby and her brothers and sisters were taught.  Was it fair?  Was it right?  How are our values about education the same or different today?

Lesson Outline:

1. Introduction:

Explain that today we’ll look at one culture’s beliefs and values about education.  Pass out bookmarks to GIRLS.  Let GIRLS sit on cushions and stools.  Explain that GIRLS will get to choose their books first today.  Expect a backlash from the boys!  This is a provocation and we want to see whether:

  1. Boys express their thoughts about the conditions not being fair.
  2. Girls speak out about the boys’ being treated unfairly

2. Main:

Teach Ruby’s Wish by Shirin Lim Bridges.  Use a “T Chart” and capture on flipchart paper beliefs about education, values about education, and  educational practices in China about 100 years ago.  Contrast that with our own beliefs and values about education.  What is the same?  What is different?  Ask the kids to think about this question:  If you lived in Ruby’s world, would you rather be a boy or a girl?  Why?

Work through the questions on the Student Handout together.

3. Conclusion:

Ask why girls were given special treatment at the beginning of class.  (Answer: Because boys were given special treatment in the story!!)  Pass out bookmarks or treats to the boys, too, and ask the kids how to try to remember how it feels to be treated unfairly or denied something that you deserve.

additional Resources:
  1. Book: Ruby’s Wish by Shirin Yim Bridges
  2. Flipchart paper (can also use Promethean Board or graphic organizers)
  3. Bookmarks, stickers, or cushions
  4. Student Handout, Ruby’s Wish
Notes:

Sometimes the group that is not favored does not stick up for themselves.  Sometimes the group that is favored does not stick up for the group that is not favored.   The dynamics of this lesson are quite unpredictable.  I have used this lesson with Grade 3 and above but I would not recommend it for younger students.  Although I have placed it in the Unit of Inquiry on cultural beliefs and values, it also fits nicely in a unit on children’s rights.

Key Terms:

Education, Educational Opportunity, Boys and Girls, Fairness, China, University, Gender Based Stereotype, Access to Education

Recommended Texts:
  1. Ruby’s Wish by Shirin Lim Bridges.
student handout:

Student Handout, Ruby’s Wish

RADCAB #3: Applying RADCAB to an Online Information Source

Lesson Overview:

In this lesson, students apply Christensson’s RADCAB model to evaluate a digital information source, usually a website.  You must prepare the guiding question and choose a website, so this will take a bit of time to set up.  I have chosen a non-professional web site that links to a unit on exploration, but you may choose any website you feel is suitable for the exercise.  This is the second lesson designed to have the kids practice using the RADCAB model.  Hopefully by now they are starting to gain some confidence in using RADCAB.  This is hard conceptual work for most 5th graders.  I often work through this exercise as a class and have them share their thinking with one another.

Lesson Plan:

Suggested Grades:

4-5

Objective:

Students will practice applying the RADCAB model to an online information source.

AASL 1.1.4:  Find, evaluate, and select appropriate sources to answer questions.

Suggested Time:

45-50 minutes

Success Criteria:

Given a guiding question and website, students will correctly assess the suitability of the website as an information source.

Lesson Outline:

1. Introduction:

Briefly review the elements of the RADCAB model.  Today we’ll be applying the model to an online information source.  The principles are the same, but the application is a bit different.  Use what you know and try to think through this assignment.  This one is more challenging than last week’s work with a print source.

2. Main:

Introduce the website, task, and activity for the day.  Students may use their own computers to access the website.  Each student will take notes and write responses to each element of the RADCAB model.  Students must explain their thinking and/or give examples.  Short or one-word answers are not enough to answer this exercise.

Work through the assignment together, if necessary.  The kids will easily get sidetracked into the content of the site and forget to evaluate the site according to the given criteria!  Keeping them on task is challenging.  You may wish to extend the lesson by 10-15 minutes, just so that they can read through the site, follow a few links, and get familiar with it before completing the assignment.

3. Conclusion:

Point out that they have:

  1. Learned the RADCAB model
  2. Applied RADCAB to a printed source (book)
  3. Applied RADCAB to an online source (website)

We will continue to use and apply RADCAB with information sources.  Encourage students to use the RADCAB model in all of their projects.

additional Resources:
  1. Website:  World Walk Travel Adventure  http://davekunst1.com/
  2. Student Handout, RADCAB Online Information Source
Notes:

You can use any website for this exercise.  However, I chose Dave Kunst’s web site because it ties to the Unit of Inquiry on exploration, the kids generally find it interesting, and he is an authority without being a large company or university.  I believe that the site is unique in this regard and therefore a good one for the kids to use in their thinking.

Karen Christensson, a library media specialist in the U.S.A,, developed the RADCAB model for her lessons in 2002.  I have found it to be an excellent tool for teaching these concepts, and I’ve never found a model I like better than hers.

I have purchased posters and bookmarks of the RADCAB model, and my students and teachers have loved them.  I have yet to find a literacy curriculum or language curriculum that teaches these concepts better than Karen’s model, so I encourage you to get familiar with it and place an order for some of the supporting materials.

RADCAB web site:  http://www.radcab.com/

Key Terms:

Information Source Evaluation, Information Literacy, RADCAB, Relevance, Appropriateness, Detail, Currency, Authority, Bias, Web Site Evaluation.

student handout:

Student Handout, RADCAB Website Evaluation

RADCAB #2: Applying RADCAB to a Printed Information Source

Lesson Overview:

In this lesson, students apply Christensson’s RADCAB model to evaluate a printed information source, usually a non-fiction book.  You must prepare the guiding questions and the books, so this will take a bit of time to set up.  The lesson provides samples, but you’ll need to use texts and relevant questions from your own collection.  Students can generally explain the model based on what they learned in the first lesson, but knowing the model and being able to use it are different skills.  I have taught this lesson for years, and most 5th grade students find it difficult to apply the concepts and explain their thinking.

Lesson Plan:

Suggested Grades:

4-5 and above

Objective:

Given a guiding question and a non-fiction book, successfully apply the RADCAB Model to evaluate the book as a suitable information source.

AASL 1.1.4:  Find, evaluate, and select appropriate sources to answer questions.

Suggested Time:

40-50 minutes

Success Criteria:

Students will successfully apply the RADCAB criteria to a printed information source.  They will record their findings/assessment, and their teacher will review their work.

Lesson Outline:

1. Introduction:

Review the RADCAB model, including what it is used for and its components.

2. Main:

Give student pairs a non-fiction text and a guiding question.  Ask them to use the RADCAB model to decide whether the information source would be suitable for answering the research question.  Students will work in pairs so that they have someone to discuss the activity with.

3. Conclusion:

State that we will be using RADCAB again next week to evaluate a website.  The model is a useful one for every research project!

additional Resources:
  1. 13 nonfiction books with guiding questions (see attached Sample Guiding Questions) .
  2. RADCAB application sheet for a print source (see attached student handout.)
Notes:

This lesson requires quite a bit more preparation effort because you will need to locate suitable books, write a matching guiding question, and have those matched and ready to go for the students before class time.

For this lesson, it is better to have the students work in pairs.  The concepts are not easy to apply and many students will benefit from talking this over with a partner.

The RADCAB model was developed by Library Media Specialist Karen Christensson.  Visit the RADCAB website here:  http://www.radcab.com/

Key Terms:

Information Source Evaluation, Information Literacy, RADCAB, Relevance, Appropriateness, Detail, Currency, Authority, Bias

Sample RADCAB guiding questions:

Sample RADCAB Guiding Questions

student handout:

Student Handout, RADCAB Printed Source Evaluation